General Counsel, P.C.

  • Practice Areas
    • Business Law
      • Business Breakups in Virginia
      • Minority Shareholder Protections
      • Emerging Companies
      • Entity Formation
      • Foreign Companies Entering U.S. Market
      • Real Estate and Leases
      • Starting a Business, Licensing & Compliance
      • Registered Agent Services
      • Succession Planning for Business Owners
      • Tax Law Matters
      • Charitable Solicitation Practice Group
      • Intellectual Property
        • Trade Secrets
        • Copyright
        • Trademark
    • Employment Law
      • Employment Documentation
        • Building Your Cornerstone
        • Employee Document Vault
        • Employee Handbook Tuneup Services
        • Guidelines for Hiring or Firing Employees
        • Separation Agreements
      • Drug Testing
        • Drug Testing Your Workforce – Best Practices
        • Laws Affecting Drug Testing Policies
      • Regulatory Issues
        • VA, MD, DC, Rights & Obligations
        • Age Discrimination
        • Americans with Disabilities Act
        • At-Will Employment
        • Fair Labor Standards Act
        • Family Medical Leave Act
        • Pregnancy Discrimination Act
        • Title VII
      • Non-Competition Agreements
        • District of Columbia
        • Maryland
        • Virginia
      • For Employers of Uniformed Services Members
      • Employer Considerations For Government Contractors
      • For Non-Profits
    • Family Law
      • Divorce
        • Grounds for Divorce
          • Fourth Level Menu Sample
        • High Net Divorce
        • Same Sex Divorce
        • Military Divorce
        • Uncontested Divorce
        • Litigation vs. Alternative Dispute Resolution in Divorce
        • Post-Divorce Enforcement and Appeals
        • Alimony and Spousal Support
        • Child Custody
        • Child Support
        • Filing for Divorce in Virginia
        • Divorce Security Clearance
      • Property Division
      • Alimony and Spousal Support
      • Child Support
      • Child Custody and Visitation
      • Marital Agreements
      • International Family Law
      • Domestic Violence and Protective Orders
      • Co-Parenting in Virginia
    • Government Contracts
      • Bid Protests
      • Government Contract Claims and Appeals
      • Getting Government Contracts: Small Business Certification Services
        • 8(a) Small Business
        • HUBZone Small Business
        • SDVOSB Program
        • Veteran-Owned Small Business
        • Women-Owned Small Business
    • Litigation
      • Arbitration, Mediation & Alternative Dispute Resolution Attorneys
      • Commercial & Business Litigation
      • Defamation
      • Employment Disputes
      • Government Contracting Disputes
      • Intellectual Property Disputes
      • Local Counsel
      • Pre-Litigation
    • Estate Planning
      • Estate Planning FAQs
      • Trusts
      • Wills
      • Families With Children
      • Business Succession Planning
      • Asset Protection Planning
      • Celebrity Estate Planning Mistakes
      • Legal Business Contingency Plans
      • Become a Referral Partner
    • Probate Administration
      • Probate is Complex – FAQ and Answers
      • Trust & Estate Litigation
  • About Us
    • Overview
    • Biographies
      • Andrew “Andy” Baxter
      • Matthew Brennan
      • Heba K. Carter
      • Joanna Foard
      • Erika Gnazzo
      • Merritt Green
      • Elizabeth Hart
      • David Kaye
      • Craig Lawless
      • David Proano
      • Evan St. John
    • How We Help
  • Resources
    • Practical Counsel Blog
    • Bid Protest Weekly
    • VetWorking
    • COVID Compliance Plans
    • Virginia COVID Workplace Safety and Health Standards
    • Video Library
    • Webinars
    • Quotes in The News
    • GCPC First Generation Law Student Scholarship
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Make Payments
703-556-0411

Who Breached First? Virginia Court Offers Guidance on Breach of Contract Claims

Wednesday, 24 August 2022 / Published in Business, Litigation

Who Breached First? Virginia Court Offers Guidance on Breach of Contract Claims

Who Breached First? Virginia Court Offers Guidance on Breach of Contract Claims

In a recent case, the Western District of Virginia provided guidance on breach of contract claims. Here, the court made clear that if one party to a contract materially breaches the contract, subsequent breaches by the other party cannot be the basis for a breach of contract claim. Under the first material breach doctrine, if the initial breach by one party is material, the other party to the contract is excused from performing his contractual obligations. Additionally, the court confirmed that a party does not waive the first material breach defense by continuing to perform after the initial material breach. 

Remy Holdings International, LLC v. Fisher Auto Parts, Inc.

Fisher Auto Parts, Inc. began purchasing automotive products from USA Industries in 1997. Fisher and USA had an agreement in 2012, which included an express provision stating “[t]his letter of understanding is predicated upon USA keeping Fisher competitive in the marketplace.” In 2014, Remy Holdings International, LLC acquired USA, and in 2015 Fisher and Remy negotiated and signed a contract entitled the First Amendment to the Letter of Understanding (the “2015 LOU”). The 2015 LOU included a provision that stated, “[t]his letter of understanding is predicated upon REMY keeping Fisher competitive in the marketplace in every way.” The 2015 LOU also included a termination provision stating that Fisher could end the contract with 60 days notice if it didn’t believe Remy provided competitive products.

Remy’s performance began to decline in 2017, including a failure to timely fill Fisher’s purchase orders. Based on Fisher’s ongoing assessment of Remy’s performance, including Remy’s inadequate efforts to keep Fisher “competitive in the marketplace in every way” and to “provide competitive products to Fisher compared to similar competitive products sold under the same market conditions,” Fisher exercised its termination right by notice dated June 18, 2018. Remy filed suit alleging Fisher breached its contract by wrongfully withholding payment under the contract and for wrongfully terminating their agreement. Remy claims that Fisher’s first breach occurred on July 1, 2018, when it provided its termination notice. Fisher counterclaimed that Remy breached the contract by failing to keep Fisher competitive in the marketplace.

In breach of contract matters, Virginia courts apply the “first material breach” doctrine. “A material breach is a failure to do something that is so fundamental to the contract that the failure to perform that obligation defeats an essential purpose of the contract. If the initial breach is material, the other party to the contract is excused from performing his contractual obligations.” Additionally, Virginia courts have rejected the argument that a party waives the first material breach defense by continuing to perform after the initial material breach.

The court here found that Remy breached the contract prior to July 1, 2018, by failing to fulfill their obligation to keep Fisher competitive in the marketplace. Remy admitted to its performance issues. The court concluded that this breach was material because it “defeats an essential purpose of the contract.” Because of this first material breach, the court determined that Remy was precluded from proceeding against Fisher for breach of contract. Although Remy argued Fisher waived the defense by continuing to order products from Remy, the court here explained that Virginia courts have rejected the argument this argument.

What Does Remy Holdings International, LLC v. Fisher Auto Parts, Inc. Mean for Businesses?

The court here offered guidance on when a breach of contract claim may be successful. Both Remy and Fisher here made claims of breach of contract. However, the court did not even reach the merits of Remy’s claims of alleged breaches by Fisher, because it determined that Remy’s breach preceded any potential breach by Fisher. In Virginia, under the first material breach doctrine, if the initial breach by one party is material, the other party to the contract is excused from performing its contractual obligations. Thus, even if Fisher did breach the contract, it was already excused from having to perform any contractual obligations since Remy materially breached the contract first. The court here also confirmed that a party does not waive the first material breach defense by continuing to perform after the initial material breach. Thus, the fact that Fisher kept performing under the contract after Remy’s initial breach did not prevent it from being able to claim the first material breach defense.

The major takeaway for businesses is that the timing of any breach of a contract is crucial to a claim. If both parties breach a contract, the party who commits the first material breach of a contract is not entitled to sue to enforce the contract terms. Thus, before bringing a claim for breach of contract, a business should consider if it materially breached the contract first. If so, the business will likely be precluded from succeeding on a breach of contract claim. Businesses should also keep in mind that even if they continued to perform under the contract after a material breach by another party, that should not necessarily stop them from bringing suit, as that is not a waiver of the defense.

If you need more guidance or information, contact the employment law experts at General Counsel, PC today at 202-360-4230. Attorneys at General Counsel, PC are specialized in labor and employment law and have experience working with business owners and individuals across Virginia, specifically in Fairfax County, Arlington, Loudoun County, and Prince William.

  • Tweet

TOP ARTICLE CATEGORIES

  • BUSINESS

  • COVID-19

  • LABOR & EMPLOYMENT

  • FAMILY LAW

  • GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS

  • LITIGATION

Subscribe to Blogs and Updates

Address:

6849 Old Dominion Dr #220
McLean, VA 22101

Hours of Operation:

Mon – Fri, 8AM – 5PM

Phone Number:

+1 703-556-0411


  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • DISCLAIMER
  • SITEMAP
  • CONTACT US
  • MAKE A PAYMENT

General Counsel, P.C. BBB Business Review

© 2023 General Counsel, P.C. | Website Design & Development by High Level Thinkers

TOP