General Counsel, P.C.

  • Practice Areas
    • Business Law
      • Business Breakups in Virginia
      • Minority Shareholder Protections
      • Emerging Companies
      • Entity Formation
      • Foreign Companies Entering U.S. Market
      • Real Estate and Leases
      • Starting a Business, Licensing & Compliance
      • Registered Agent Services
      • Succession Planning for Business Owners
      • Tax Law Matters
      • Charitable Solicitation Practice Group
      • Intellectual Property
        • Trade Secrets
        • Copyright
        • Trademark
    • Employment Law
      • Employment Documentation
        • Building Your Cornerstone
        • Employee Document Vault
        • Employee Handbook Tuneup Services
        • Guidelines for Hiring or Firing Employees
        • Separation Agreements
      • Drug Testing
        • Drug Testing Your Workforce – Best Practices
        • Laws Affecting Drug Testing Policies
      • Regulatory Issues
        • VA, MD, DC, Rights & Obligations
        • Age Discrimination
        • Americans with Disabilities Act
        • At-Will Employment
        • Fair Labor Standards Act
        • Family Medical Leave Act
        • Pregnancy Discrimination Act
        • Title VII
      • Non-Competition Agreements
        • District of Columbia
        • Maryland
        • Virginia
      • For Employers of Uniformed Services Members
      • Employer Considerations For Government Contractors
      • For Non-Profits
    • Family Law
      • Divorce
        • Grounds for Divorce
          • Fourth Level Menu Sample
        • High Net Divorce
        • Same Sex Divorce
        • Military Divorce
        • Uncontested Divorce
        • Litigation vs. Alternative Dispute Resolution in Divorce
        • Post-Divorce Enforcement and Appeals
        • Alimony and Spousal Support
        • Child Custody
        • Child Support
        • Filing for Divorce in Virginia
        • Divorce Security Clearance
      • Property Division
      • Alimony and Spousal Support
      • Child Support
      • Child Custody and Visitation
      • Marital Agreements
      • International Family Law
      • Domestic Violence and Protective Orders
      • Co-Parenting in Virginia
    • Government Contracts
      • Bid Protests
      • Government Contract Claims and Appeals
      • Getting Government Contracts: Small Business Certification Services
        • 8(a) Small Business
        • HUBZone Small Business
        • SDVOSB Program
        • Veteran-Owned Small Business
        • Women-Owned Small Business
    • Litigation
      • Arbitration, Mediation & Alternative Dispute Resolution Attorneys
      • Commercial & Business Litigation
      • Defamation
      • Employment Disputes
      • Government Contracting Disputes
      • Intellectual Property Disputes
      • Local Counsel
      • Pre-Litigation
    • Estate Planning
      • Estate Planning FAQs
      • Trusts
      • Wills
      • Families With Children
      • Business Succession Planning
      • Asset Protection Planning
      • Celebrity Estate Planning Mistakes
      • Legal Business Contingency Plans
      • Become a Referral Partner
    • Probate Administration
      • Probate is Complex – FAQ and Answers
      • Trust & Estate Litigation
  • About Us
    • Overview
    • Biographies
      • Andrew “Andy” Baxter
      • Matthew Brennan
      • Heba K. Carter
      • Joanna Foard
      • Erika Gnazzo
      • Merritt Green
      • Elizabeth Hart
      • David Kaye
      • Craig Lawless
      • David Proano
      • Evan St. John
    • How We Help
  • Resources
    • Practical Counsel Blog
    • Bid Protest Weekly
    • VetWorking
    • COVID Compliance Plans
    • Virginia COVID Workplace Safety and Health Standards
    • Video Library
    • Webinars
    • Quotes in The News
    • GCPC First Generation Law Student Scholarship
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Make Payments
703-556-0411

Unauthorized Computer Access by Former Employee – Protection of Trade Secrets

Thursday, 27 April 2017 / Published in Labor & Employment

Unauthorized Computer Access by Former Employee – Protection of Trade Secrets

Case: Estes Forwarding Worldwide LLC v. Cuellar, (E.D. Va. Mar. 09, 2017)

Holding: The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia denied former employee’s motion to dismiss finding that employer sufficiently plead facts to assert violations of Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and the Stored Communications Act.

Employment Counsel: State and Federal laws protect computer and other electronically stored information from unauthorized computer access.  Employers must establish, maintain, and monitor employee access to such electronic databases and ensure that at termination of employment, access is terminated.  Further, employment agreements should specifically identify post-employment restrictions to any employment related electronically stored information. Finally, there are numerous state and federal laws protecting trade secrets and electronically stored information.  Employers should be aware of such laws and utilize them to protect their confidential information.

Case Summary:  In 2010, Marcelo Cuellar, the defendant, began working for the plaintiff, Estes Forwarding Worldwide LLC (“EFW”) in its San Francisco operations unit.  As part of his employment, Cuellar created a Google Drive account (“the account”) that he and other EFW employees used to record daily company transactions.  EFW considered these recordings to be trade secrets. In February 2015, EFW fired Cuellar. He subsequently went to work for a competitor. However, a year after his termination, Cuellar accessed the EFW account, downloaded information from it, and changed its password. Google notified EFW about the unauthorized access, which then prompted EFW to pursue a costly investigation to discover the identity of the unauthorized user.

Upon discovering that the user was Cuellar, EFW filed a complaint against him alleging eight (8) causes of action, including: (1) breach of contract (confidentiality agreement); (2) violations of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (“CFAA”); (3) violation of the Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016; (4) violation of the Stored Communications Act; (5) misappropriation of trade secrets pursuant to VA Code Ann. §§59.1-336; (6) violation of Virginia Computer Crimes Act; and (7) seeking preliminary and permanent injunction.

Cueller filed a motion to dismiss challenging the CFAA and SCA causes of action.  

The court held that in order to establish that Cuellar violated the CFAA and the SCA, EFW had to show that Cuellar’s use of the Google account that he helped create was unauthorized or exceeded his authorization. Cuellar argued that his access to the account was authorized because when a person provides personal information to create an account with Google, it is the service provider, not the employer, who grants authorization for account access. The court, however, pointed out that Cuellar created the account while “acting in the course and scope of his employment and for the benefit of EFW, not for personal use.”  It then pointed to the Fourth Circuit’s reasoning that a person “exceeds authorized access” when “he has approval to access a computer, but uses his access to obtain or alter information that falls outside the bounds of his approved access.” Since the account was not Cuellar’s personal account, but rather created in the scope of his employment and used for EFW’s benefit, the court reasoned that Cuellar’s access to it post-employment was unauthorized.

For additional information about unauthorized computer access, and about this case or other employment law matters, please contact Merritt Green at mgreen@gcpc.com or (703)556-6505.  Mr. Green leads General Counsel, P.C.’s Employment Law Practice and has been representing employers (and occasionally employees) for over 19 years.

  • Tweet

TOP ARTICLE CATEGORIES

  • BUSINESS

  • COVID-19

  • LABOR & EMPLOYMENT

  • FAMILY LAW

  • GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS

  • LITIGATION

Subscribe to Blogs and Updates

Address:

6849 Old Dominion Dr #220
McLean, VA 22101

Hours of Operation:

Mon – Fri, 8AM – 5PM

Phone Number:

+1 703-556-0411


  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • DISCLAIMER
  • SITEMAP
  • CONTACT US
  • MAKE A PAYMENT

General Counsel, P.C. BBB Business Review

© 2023 General Counsel, P.C. | Website Design & Development by High Level Thinkers

TOP