General Counsel, P.C.

  • Practice Areas
    • Business Law
      • Business Breakups in Virginia
      • Contract Management
      • Minority Shareholder Protections
      • Emerging Companies
      • Entity Formation
      • Foreign Companies Entering U.S. Market
      • Real Estate and Leases
      • Starting a Business, Licensing & Compliance
      • Registered Agent Services
      • Succession Planning for Business Owners
      • Tax Law Matters
      • Charitable Solicitation Practice Group
      • Intellectual Property
        • Trade Secrets
        • Copyright
        • Trademark
    • Employment Law
      • Employment Documentation
        • Building Your Cornerstone
        • Employee Document Vault
        • Employee Handbook Tuneup Services
        • Guidelines for Hiring or Firing Employees
        • Separation Agreements
      • Drug Testing
        • Drug Testing Your Workforce – Best Practices
        • Laws Affecting Drug Testing Policies
      • Regulatory Issues
        • VA, MD, DC, Rights & Obligations
        • Age Discrimination
        • Americans with Disabilities Act
        • At-Will Employment
        • Fair Labor Standards Act
        • Family Medical Leave Act
        • Pregnancy Discrimination Act
        • Title VII
      • Non-Competition Agreements
        • District of Columbia
        • Maryland
        • Virginia
      • For Employers of Uniformed Services Members
      • Employer Considerations For Government Contractors
      • For Non-Profits
    • Family Law
      • Divorce
        • Collaborative Divorce
        • Grounds for Divorce
          • Fourth Level Menu Sample
        • High Net Divorce
        • Same Sex Divorce
        • Military Divorce
        • Uncontested Divorce
        • Litigation vs. Alternative Dispute Resolution in Divorce
        • Post-Divorce Enforcement and Appeals
        • Alimony and Spousal Support
        • Child Custody
        • Child Support
        • Filing for Divorce in Virginia
        • Divorce Security Clearance
      • Property Division
      • Alimony and Spousal Support
      • Child Support
      • Child Custody and Visitation
      • Marital Agreements
      • International Family Law
      • Domestic Violence and Protective Orders
      • Co-Parenting in Virginia
    • Government Contracts
      • Bid Protests
      • Government Contract Claims and Appeals
      • Getting Government Contracts: Small Business Certification Services
        • 8(a) Small Business
        • HUBZone Small Business
        • SDVOSB Program
        • Veteran-Owned Small Business
        • Women-Owned Small Business
    • Litigation
      • Arbitration, Mediation & Alternative Dispute Resolution Attorneys
      • Commercial & Business Litigation
      • Defamation
      • Employment Disputes
      • Government Contracting Disputes
      • Intellectual Property Disputes
      • Local Counsel
      • Pre-Litigation
    • Estate Planning
      • Estate Planning FAQs
      • Trusts
      • Wills
      • Families With Children
      • Business Succession Planning
      • Asset Protection Planning
      • Celebrity Estate Planning Mistakes
      • Legal Business Contingency Plans
      • Become a Referral Partner
    • Probate Administration
      • Probate is Complex – FAQ and Answers
      • Trust & Estate Litigation
  • About Us
    • Overview
    • Biographies
      • Heba K. Carter
      • Grace Clagett
      • Elizabeth Hart
      • David Kaye
      • Alexis Ruark
    • Our Founder
    • How We Help
  • Resources
    • Practical Counsel Blog
    • Bid Protest Weekly
    • VetWorking
    • Video Library
    • Webinars
    • Quotes in The News
    • GCPC First Generation Law Student Scholarship
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Make Payments
703-556-0411

Should Your Business Consider A Business Interruption Lawsuit Against Your Insurance Company

Thursday, 27 August 2020 / Published in Business, Litigation

Should Your Business Consider A Business Interruption Lawsuit Against Your Insurance Company

Closed Store

A recent decision in the Western District of Missouri may have set the stage for “business interruption” coverage for businesses for losses resulting from COVID-19. Business interruption insurance replaces lost income when a business has to temporarily close. The policies generally apply when there’s “direct physical loss or damage.” “Direct physical loss or damage” typically applies to events including burst pipes, fires, or damage from other disasters. In the midst of the coronavirus pandemic, the question becomes whether or not the insurance applies when businesses are required to close under government orders.

While previously courts in Michigan and Washington, D.C. sided with insurance carriers and held that such coverage wasn’t warranted because COVID-19 doesn’t cause “physical loss or damage,” a Missouri court held that a group of nail salons and restaurants may pursue claims for business income losses due to COVID-19. The plaintiffs in Studio 417 Inc. v Cincinnati Insurance Co. followed city and state shutdown orders from Kansas and Missouri that went from March to May and resulted in loss of business income. The court found that “physical loss” should be broadly construed. The plaintiffs argued that COVID-19 particles were a “physical substance” which attached to and damaged their property, resulting in the property being unsafe and unusable.

Have a possible dispute with your insurance? Contact us!

The Court determined that the plaintiffs “adequately stated a claim for direct physical loss,” holding that “because the Policies do not define a direct ‘physical loss’ the Court must ‘rely on the plain and ordinary meaning of the phrase.’” The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines “direct” in part as “characterized by close logical, causal, or consequential relationship.” Since “physical” is defined as “having material existence: perceptible especially through the senses and subject to the laws of nature” and “loss” is “the act of losing possession” and “deprivation,” the court held that the plaintiffs alleged a direct physical loss. It’s important to note that the plaintiff’s policies had no exclusion for economic fallout from viruses. Business owners with policies that do include such an exclusion will likely face an additional hurdle.

Across the county, business owners have been submitting claims for business interruption for loss of business income due to COVID-19 related closures. Insurance companies have largely denied these claims, similarly reasoning that the presence or risk of the virus, and related business closures, to not rise to the level of “direct physical loss or damage.” This has resulted in hundreds of lawsuits being filed across the country.

This decision seems to be the first known victory for policyholders in suing their insurers for improperly denying claims related to losses caused by the shutdowns due to COVID-19. While the court here did not decide on the merits of the ultimate claims, the decision is a significant step for policyholders seeking to secure business interruption coverage for lost profits and other expenses resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. The court’s ruling here could have broad implications for other businesses as they begin to sue their insurance carriers for denying similar claims. This decision can be used as persuasive authority for business owners trying to establish the “direct physical loss” requirement.

If your business was forced to close, or otherwise affected by COVID-19 related shut-down orders, you may be entitled to insurance proceeds based on your lost business income. Attorneys at General Counsel, P.C. can help you understand and protect your rights. Call us today at 703-991-7973.

  • Tweet

TOP ARTICLE CATEGORIES

  • BUSINESS

  • LABOR & EMPLOYMENT

  • FAMILY LAW

  • GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS

  • LITIGATION

Subscribe to Blogs and Updates

Name
Areas of Interest:
The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

Consent(Required)

Address:

1320 Old Chain Bridge Road, #440
McLean, VA 22101

Hours of Operation:

Mon – Fri, 8AM – 5PM

Phone Number:

+1 703-556-0411


  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • DISCLAIMER
  • SITEMAP
  • CONTACT US
  • MAKE A PAYMENT

General Counsel, P.C. BBB Business Review

© 2025 General Counsel, P.C. | Website Design & Development by High Level Thinkers

TOP