General Counsel, P.C.

  • Practice Areas
    • Business Law
      • Business Breakups in Virginia
      • Minority Shareholder Protections
      • Emerging Companies
      • Entity Formation
      • Foreign Companies Entering U.S. Market
      • Real Estate and Leases
      • Starting a Business, Licensing & Compliance
      • Registered Agent Services
      • Succession Planning for Business Owners
      • Tax Law Matters
      • Charitable Solicitation Practice Group
      • Intellectual Property
        • Trade Secrets
        • Copyright
        • Trademark
    • Employment Law
      • Employment Documentation
        • Building Your Cornerstone
        • Employee Document Vault
        • Employee Handbook Tuneup Services
        • Guidelines for Hiring or Firing Employees
        • Separation Agreements
      • Drug Testing
        • Drug Testing Your Workforce – Best Practices
        • Laws Affecting Drug Testing Policies
      • Regulatory Issues
        • VA, MD, DC, Rights & Obligations
        • Age Discrimination
        • Americans with Disabilities Act
        • At-Will Employment
        • Fair Labor Standards Act
        • Family Medical Leave Act
        • Pregnancy Discrimination Act
        • Title VII
      • Non-Competition Agreements
        • District of Columbia
        • Maryland
        • Virginia
      • For Employers of Uniformed Services Members
      • Employer Considerations For Government Contractors
      • For Non-Profits
    • Family Law
      • Divorce
        • Grounds for Divorce
          • Fourth Level Menu Sample
        • High Net Divorce
        • Same Sex Divorce
        • Military Divorce
        • Uncontested Divorce
        • Litigation vs. Alternative Dispute Resolution in Divorce
        • Post-Divorce Enforcement and Appeals
        • Alimony and Spousal Support
        • Child Custody
        • Child Support
        • Filing for Divorce in Virginia
        • Divorce Security Clearance
      • Property Division
      • Alimony and Spousal Support
      • Child Support
      • Child Custody and Visitation
      • Marital Agreements
      • International Family Law
      • Domestic Violence and Protective Orders
      • Co-Parenting in Virginia
    • Government Contracts
      • Bid Protests
      • Government Contract Claims and Appeals
      • Getting Government Contracts: Small Business Certification Services
        • 8(a) Small Business
        • HUBZone Small Business
        • SDVOSB Program
        • Veteran-Owned Small Business
        • Women-Owned Small Business
    • Litigation
      • Arbitration, Mediation & Alternative Dispute Resolution Attorneys
      • Commercial & Business Litigation
      • Defamation
      • Employment Disputes
      • Government Contracting Disputes
      • Intellectual Property Disputes
      • Local Counsel
      • Pre-Litigation
    • Estate Planning
      • Estate Planning FAQs
      • Trusts
      • Wills
      • Families With Children
      • Business Succession Planning
      • Asset Protection Planning
      • Celebrity Estate Planning Mistakes
      • Legal Business Contingency Plans
      • Become a Referral Partner
    • Probate Administration
      • Probate is Complex – FAQ and Answers
      • Trust & Estate Litigation
  • About Us
    • Overview
    • Biographies
      • Andrew “Andy” Baxter
      • Matthew Brennan
      • Heba K. Carter
      • Joanna Foard
      • Erika Gnazzo
      • Merritt Green
      • Elizabeth Hart
      • David Kaye
      • Craig Lawless
      • David Proano
      • Evan St. John
    • How We Help
  • Resources
    • Practical Counsel Blog
    • Bid Protest Weekly
    • VetWorking
    • COVID Compliance Plans
    • Virginia COVID Workplace Safety and Health Standards
    • Video Library
    • Webinars
    • Quotes in The News
    • GCPC First Generation Law Student Scholarship
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Make Payments
703-556-0411

D.C. Employment Update: Proving Title VII Employment Discrimination No Longer Requires Showing of Tangible Harm following Request or Denial of Job Transfer

Wednesday, 10 August 2022 / Published in Labor & Employment

D.C. Employment Update: Proving Title VII Employment Discrimination No Longer Requires Showing of Tangible Harm following Request or Denial of Job Transfer

In a June 3 decision that impacts D.C. employers, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit overruled its own precedent, holding that discriminatory job transfers are actionable under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The Court held that where an employer denies an employee’s request for a job transfer because of the employee’s sex, race, color, religion, or national origin, the employer has discriminated against the employee with respect to the “terms, conditions, or privileges of employment.”

This decision overrules the Court’s 1999 ruling in Brown v. Brody, where it held that that the forced acceptance or denial of a job transfer is actionable under Title VII only if the employee suffered “objectively tangible harm.” Now, D.C. employees will be protected against all discrimination under Title VII that is plainly within the Title.

This new precedent comes after D.C. Attorney General’s office employee, Mary Chambers, brought suit against the District of Columbia. Ms. Chambers served as a clerk and later as a Support Enforcement Specialist and investigator, having worked in the office for more than twenty years. Chambers claimed that her employer denied her repeated requests for a transfer to a different unit despite granting similar requests of male employees. As a result, she filed an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission charge and eventually brought this lawsuit, alleging that she experienced discrimination and retaliation on the basis of sex.

The core Title VII inquiry, which applies to employers in both the private and public sectors that have more than 15 employees, is whether an employer has discriminated against an employee based on a protected characteristic. An employer has discriminated against an employee when it has “fail[ed] or refuse[d] to hire or to discharge any individual, or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to his compensation, terms, conditions, or privileges of employment because of such individual’s race, color, religion, sex, or national origin…”

What does this mean for D.C. employers, and what actions should they take?

The Court’s decision in Chambers made clear that refusing a transfer request for one employee while granting a similar request of a similarly situated employee on the basis of a protected characteristic is discriminatory because it “deprives the employee of a job opportunity.”

In light of the Chambers decision, when an employee requests a job transfer, the employer must consider any potential disadvantage to the employee in denying that request. If the employer chooses to deny the request, it is critical that the employer document the legitimate non-discriminatory business reason for doing so to avoid a potential claim against it.

It should be noted, however, that the Chambers’ decision has posed the question as to whether the recent ruling applies to other employment actions such as the denial of awards or training opportunities, or the assignment of specific work shifts. While Title VII does not cover all employer decisions that make an employee unhappy, Chambers may raise the possibility of other potentially discriminatory employment actions being covered.

General Counsel, P.C. would like to thank Kristian Loomis, Esq. for her assistance researching and writing this article. For additional information, please contact General Counsel, P.C. or email us at info@gcpc.com.  For information about our employment law practice, you can contact Merritt Green at mgreen@gcpc.com.

  • Tweet

TOP ARTICLE CATEGORIES

  • BUSINESS

  • COVID-19

  • LABOR & EMPLOYMENT

  • FAMILY LAW

  • GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS

  • LITIGATION

Subscribe to Blogs and Updates

Address:

6849 Old Dominion Dr #220
McLean, VA 22101

Hours of Operation:

Mon – Fri, 8AM – 5PM

Phone Number:

+1 703-556-0411


  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • DISCLAIMER
  • SITEMAP
  • CONTACT US
  • MAKE A PAYMENT

General Counsel, P.C. BBB Business Review

© 2023 General Counsel, P.C. | Website Design & Development by High Level Thinkers

TOP